- Serena - An ace bandage so she can wrap her breasts Hilary Swank in Boys Don't Cry-style and get them down to a normal feminine contour and a turtleneck
- Blair - For Chuck to recreate the opening scene of Sweet Home Alabama
- Nate - A new dad
- Chuck - Rangers puck signed by the whole team and Nate's new dad if it doesn't work out with Nate
- Jenny - Placebos to replace the Ritalin they obviously put her on when she came back home after being on the verge of emancipating herself
- Dan - First edition copies of Ulysses and Dubliners by James Joyce and a new pair of pants to change into after he unwraps the books
- Rufus - A world tour with Jesse and the Rippers*
- Lily - Backstage passes to above world tour
- Eric - More backstage passes
- Dorota - A free pass to do or say anything she wants to the Waldorfs**
* - Yesss!
** - I would like this to be youtubed.